Requiem for a Relic: The Case of the Great Northern Grain Elevator

Abstract

Works of architecture are frequently valued for the distinctive profiles they lend to a cityscape, and when beautiful buildings
fall into disrepair, reference to their aesthetic merit can support efforts for preservation and restoration. However, many historically important structures, such as industrial buildings, do not possess obvious aesthetic virtues, in the sense that their appearance is not immediately appealing. Consider an object such as the gigantic Great Northern grain elevator,
which was built in 1897 and stood near the western terminus of the Erie Canal. This last of the “brick box” elevators was demolished in 2023 after preservation efforts mobilized on its behalf failed. It was not obviously beautiful, but its historical position conferred significant aesthetic merits.